Business Executive Coaching

Coaching Business Owners and Executive Teams

  • ABOUT
    • Pitstop Coaches
  • COACHING
  • TEAM PROGRAMS
    • Priority Track
    • Critical Teams
    • Critical Projects
    • What Happens When the Adrenaline is Gone?
    • Strategy Under Pressure
    • COVID-19
    • Clarity on Results
    • First Mile
    • Project Double Jeopardy
    • Ways of Working
  • PRAISE
  • PODCAST
  • Blog
  • CONTACT
  • BOOK A CALL
  • ABOUT
    • Pitstop Coaches
  • COACHING
  • TEAM PROGRAMS
    • Priority Track
    • Critical Teams
    • Critical Projects
    • What Happens When the Adrenaline is Gone?
    • Strategy Under Pressure
    • COVID-19
    • Clarity on Results
    • First Mile
    • Project Double Jeopardy
    • Ways of Working
  • PRAISE
  • PODCAST
  • Blog
  • CONTACT
  • BOOK A CALL

search

Project Double Jeopardy: The Dangers of Hidden Complexity & Misplaced Certainty – Growth Pitstop

Project Double Jeopardy: The Dangers of Hidden Complexity & Misplaced Certainty
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=keA0vIi5ZnQ

Complex projects and initiatives are exposed to the twin dangers of unseen complexity and misplaced certainty. Think of it as ‘Project Double Jeopardy’ because if one does not get you, the other just might1.

The concept of double jeopardy will be familiar to fans of courtroom drama. It is a legal defence which means that a suspect, if acquitted, cannot be tried a second time for the same offence. That is interesting here too – because any defence against unseen complexity, will also protect a project against misplaced certainty.

Misplaced Certainty

If you read the statistics relating to project frustration and even failure, it is evident there is a lot of misplaced certainty going around. The much publicized reports suggest that most projects and initiatives are either over time, over budget or otherwise failing to meet expectations.

The evidence points to a systematic pattern of misplaced certainty. Those charged with making projects happen are habitually underestimating just how complex delivering successful projects actually is. Moreover, traditional project management methods strive for certainty – with budgets, timelines and results being set at the start of a project and are rigidly adhered to thereafter.

Rising Complexity

Most strategic initiatives have a high level of complexity. They have many moving parts and defy the quick fix or silver bullet.  They are difficult to manage or predict and cannot be solved by traditional linear approaches.

The problem is that when initiatives are simplified that is exactly what happens – problems are handed over to one or a few experts who break them down into the component parts and work on them in isolation and applying technical solutions when more is needed.

How complex is your initiative? On a scale from 1 to 10, where 1 is ‘simple’ and 10 is ‘complex’. Where would you put your project or initiative? Gather a range of perspectives and use the table here as a checklist.

Unseen Complexity

If you have been reading business books and articles long enough you will likely remember a time when the phrase KISS (keep it simple, stupid!) was in vogue.  Those were simpler times!   Today’s world is a lot more complex and the challenge for leaders is to embrace complexity, rather than to keep it simple.

‘Seeing around corners’ – that is how leading business writer Rita McGrath sums up the challenges of executing strategic initiates2. It is another way of communicating complexity and uncertainty. When you cannot ‘see around the corner’ the temptation is to slow down. In times of accelerating change that is a problem – those who slow down risk being overtaken.

The Tendency to Simplify

Our brains are designed to simplify – that is an important part of their power and can be highly functional3.  However, in complex situations, simplification is not always the best solution.

Over-simplification is a by-product of a range of cognitive heuristics and biases4. It can be seen in the temptation to:

  • Look for a quick fix – underestimating the requirements of sustaining or embedding change
  • Work on the parts rather than the whole
  • Adopt a piecemeal rather than a systematic approach
  • Work on symptoms rather than the underlying causes
  • See change as purely a matter of technology or skill (i.e. technical), without appreciating the need to change mindset and behaviour (i.e. adaptive)
  • Turn to experts for the solution.

Over & Under-Estimating

All the above factors are a product of our natural cognitive drive to simplify. However, the result of such unseen complexity means it is easy to overestimate what can be achieved and to underestimate what it will take (including budget and timelines).  Put another way, the result is misplaced certainty regarding:

  • Timelines, budgets and deliverables
  • Business or stakeholder needs and market trends
  • The future of an industry, business model or technology, etc.

Such misplaced certainty can result in a false sense of security and leaves a team vulnerable to shocks and surprises. The problem is not complexity, but rather unseen complexity. The danger exists when the complexity of any project or initiative is underestimated. It leaves people unprepared to deal with the opportunities and challenges that are ahead. Simplifying the complex can result in chaos.

There is a high level of uncertainty with respect to the delivery of most strategic projects and initiatives, especially those that are ‘business unusual’, rather than ‘business as unusual‘. Quite simply there may be no reference point where – a past project or experience – that you can point to and say this is how it will work and here are the results we can expect. So, estimates as regards budget, time, resource and deliverables are purely that – estimates. Just because they get put into a plan or a Gantt Chart does not make them anything more than estimates.

“Success requires leaders to demonstrate the courage to choose before the data is clear, the clarity to focus on the highest-potential opportunities, the curiosity to explore in the face of uncertainty, and the conviction to persevere in the face of predictable crises.”

Scott D. Anthony, Clark G. Gilbert & Mark W. Johnson5

Engaging with Complexity

Complex projects require engaging multiple actors and multiple perspectives, working on the whole rather than the parts and adaptive (requiring a change of thinking or behaviour) as well as technical solutions. They demand greater creativity and innovation, as well as curiosity and experimentation. The approach must be an agile or iterative one, where there is fast learning and continuous feedback.

When you add up the requirements for agility, innovation, teamwork and collaboration, it all amounts to new ways of working on projects and teams. That presents challenges for organizations with a top-down hierarchy and functional boundaries, where multi-year planning cycles, bureaucratic approvals committees and departmental silos constrain speed and agility, as well as collaboration and innovation.

Complex projects are typically more exciting than simple projects.  The challenges they entail present opportunities for learning and growth.  They present opportunities for people to fully utilize and develop their full talents and skill, to add to their resumes and build their professional network. They also reveal what organizations and teams are capable of, building levels of teamwork and collaboration.

 

Complicated or Complex?
There is complicated and there is complex6. That may sound like a play on words, but think of it this way:  A jig saw may be complicated with many parts. However, a Rubik’s Cube is complex, not only does it have many parts but they interact with each other – if you move one then the others are affected too.  That is a key factor that distinguishes complex projects – you cannot work on one part (stakeholder, risk, work stream, etc.) in isolation. Take the launch of a new Financial Services Product, marketing cannot work in isolation of IT, Compliance or Finance for example.  All the parts must work well together – effective cross-functional collaboration is key.

Embracing Uncertainty

‘No doubt – no opportunity’ said the experienced senior executive.  If a project leader is convinced that they have all the answers, they will likely be closed to  new ideas, possibilities or outcomes.  Unless there is a little crack in their confidence or certainty, where doubt can penetrate,  the team is at risk of misplaced certainty.

For a team this misplaced certainty can be magnified with the power of group think coming in to place.  People are likely to go with the flow rather than question the ‘wisdom of the group’. This is a key reason why projects are blind-sided by risks that could have been foreseen. Ensuring the safety of a project requires creating an environment where there is psychological safety, as well as respectful challenge, intellectual humility and sufficient variety.

Engaging with complexity means
engaging:

  • Divergent Perspectives
  • Assumptions
  • Testable Hypotheses
  • Scenarios
  • Risks
  • Dependencies
  • Etc.

It also means trading certainty for:

  • Dialog
  • Curiosity
  • Intellectual Humility
  • Experimentation
  • Agility
  • Fast Learning

Silos Over-simplify

There is unseen complexity, when a project or initiative is looked at through the lens of just one function or discipline.  For example, compliance sees a project through its cautious legal lens, but is likely to have only a limited appreciation of marketing’s growth lens or Finance’s numbers lens.

When the various functions combine their different lens, the result is a kaleidoscopic view of a project. It is then that the full complexity can be seen. This happens when different perspectives are combined – not just technical – but generational, cultural and so on. Making sense of this kaleidoscopic view requires effective teamwork and cross-functional collaboration.

Our data suggests that the risk of unseen complexity is greatest where an initiative represents a solo-run by one department or function.  Engaging with complexity requires breaking down silos and effective cross-functional collaboration.

Caught up in the day to day busyness of a project, those involved can lose sight of the needs of the business and the realities of its market. This ‘project myopia‘ is an important cause of unseen complexity.

 

Source of Complexity
Our research points to the importance of distinguishing between internal and external complexity.   For some organizations there is considerable complexity owing to internal factors, such as dealing with internal bureaucracy, trying to get cooperation across silos,  managing internal stakeholders, juggling competing priorities,  navigating internal politics and so on.

These internal factors have the potential to generate much noise and interference. Also, to generate a considerable degree of non-value added work and the frustration that accompanies it. The result is that project leaders can spend a lot of their time and energy focused internally, rather than externally. Internal complexity make responding to external complexity (e.g. new technology, business modes or channels) more difficult.

What is Knowable & When

“It is so obvious – if only I had known that some years ago!”  That is a common reaction to the concept of ‘The Cone of Uncertainty‘.  It shows how project estimates – time, budget, results and so on, start off disparate but get more accurate or reliable over time.  The message is that you can only see so far ahead. Certainty at the outset is dangerous7.

Naturally, levels of uncertainty are high at the start (i.e. the first mile), with confidence and clarity increasing as progress is made. This is shown in the cone-shaped graph below.  A high level of uncertainty is not necessarily a problem – that is unless your planning and budgeting cycle tries to deny it with misplaced certainty regarding results, timelines, etc.

The Cone of Uncertainty points to the importance of an iterative approach, including the phasing of projects and in particular the importance of a discovery / exploratory phase.  It does not take away from the need to clearly set out your plan (including milestones, deliverables, etc.) at the start, but highlights the need to update regularly as you progress.  This happens naturally when you adopt an agile approach with an effective plan-do-review rhythm.

Hidden Complexity and Misplaced Confidence (i.e. Project Double Jeopardy) are among of the many variables measured by Pitstop Analytics™.

  1. Double Jeopardy is a legal defence to prevent a person being tried twice for the same offence, one acquitted [↩]
  2. ((Rita McGrath & Clayton Christensen, ‘Seeing Around Corners: How to Spot Inflection Points in Business Before They Happen’, Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 2019 [↩]
  3. Mats Alvesson & André Spicer use the term ‘functional stupidity’ to describe both the power and the pitfalls of simplification an in particular ‘the inclination to reduce one’s scope of thinking and focus only on the narrow, technical aspects of the job.’ see ‘The Stupidity Paradox: The Power and Pitfalls of Functional Stupidity at Work’. Profile Books, 2016 [↩]
  4. Here is what Chris Bradley, Martin Hirt & Sven Smit say about the role of bias in executive decision-making:  “Strategy processes really are in the running for the world’s biggest zoo of frolicking biases and social distortions.” See: Strategy Beyond the Hockey Stick: People, Probabilities, and Big Moves to Beat the Odds, Wiley, 2018. [↩]
  5. Scott D. Anthony, Clark G. Gilbert & Mark W. Johnson, “Dual Transformation: How to Reposition Today’s Business While Creating the Future”, HBR Press, 2017 [↩]
  6. See The Cynefin Framework by Kurtz and Snowden in “The New Dynamics of Strategy, IBM Systems Journal 2003” [↩]
  7. Explore the Cone of Uncertainty in its original software development context at http://www.agilenutshell.com/cone_of_uncertainty [↩]

John Murphy
Email Us

Footer Links

  • ABOUT
  • COACHING
  • TEAM PROGRAMS
  • PRAISE
  • PODCAST
  • BLOG
  • CONTACT

Copyright Menu

  • © JohnMurphyInternational
  • All Rights Reserved
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Site Map

Social Menu

Access My Industry-Leading Knowledge Bank of Leadership Content ’10 Key Traits of Top Leaders’ eBook

Enhance your leadership skills and take your business and team to the next level with my free eBook containing many of the strategies I teach Fortune 500 company leaders.

We will only send you awesome stuff

Privacy Policy

Privacy Policy

1.   INTRODUCTION

This privacy notice provides you with details of how we collect and process your personal data through your use of our site johnmurphyinternational.com

By providing us with your data, you warrant to us that you are over 16 years of age.

Focus Point Ltd T/A John Murphy International is the data controller and we are responsible for your personal data (referred to as “we”, “us” or “our” in this privacy notice).

Contact Details

Full name of legal entity: Focus Point Ltd T/A John Murphy International

Name of Data Controller: John Murphy

Email address: info@johnmurphyinternational.com

Postal address: 9 Exchange Place, IFSC, Dublin 1, Ireland

It is very important that the information we hold about you is accurate and up to date. Please let us know if at any time your personal information changes by emailing us at info@johnmurphyinternational.com.

2.  WHAT DATA DO WE COLLECT ABOUT YOU, FOR WHAT PURPOSE AND ON WHAT GROUND WE PROCESS IT

Personal data means any information capable of identifying an individual. It does not include anonymised data.

We may process the following categories of personal data about you:

Communication Data that includes any communication that you send to us whether that be through the contact form on our website, through email, text, social media messaging, social media posting or any other communication that you send us. We process this data for the purposes of communicating with you, for record keeping and for the establishment, pursuance or defence of legal claims. Our lawful ground for this processing is our legitimate interests which in this case are to reply to communications sent to us, to keep records and to establish, pursue or defend legal claims.

Customer Data that includes data relating to any purchases of services such as your name, title, address, email address and phone number. We process this data to supply services you have purchased and to keep records of such transactions. Our lawful ground for this processing is the performance of a contract between you and us and/or taking steps at your request to enter into such a contract.

User Data that includes data about how you use our website and any online services together with any data that you post for publication on our website or through other online services. We process this data to operate our website and ensure relevant content is provided to you, to ensure the security of our website, to maintain back-ups of our website and/or databases and to enable publication and administration of our website, other online services and business. Our lawful ground for this processing is our legitimate interests which in this case are to enable us to properly administer our website and our business.

Technical Data that includes data about your use of our website and online services such as your IP address, your login data, details about your browser, length of visit to pages on our website, page views and navigation paths, details about the number of times you use our website, time zone settings and other technology on the devices you use to access our website. The source of this data is from our analytics tracking system. We process this data to analyse your use of our website and other online services, to administer and protect our business and website, to deliver relevant website content and advertisements to you and to understand the effectiveness of our advertising. Our lawful ground for this processing is our legitimate interests which in this case are to enable us to properly administer our website and our business and to grow our business and to decide our marketing strategy.

Marketing Data that includes data about your preferences in receiving marketing from us and your communication preferences. We process this data to deliver relevant website content and advertisements to you and measure or understand the effectiveness of this advertising. Our lawful ground for this processing is our legitimate interests which in this case are to study how customers use our services, to develop them, to grow our business and to decide our marketing strategy.

We may use Customer Data, User Data, Technical Data and Marketing Data to deliver relevant website content and advertisements to you (including Facebook adverts or other display advertisements) and to measure or understand the effectiveness of the advertising we serve you. Our lawful ground for this processing is legitimate interests which is to grow our business. We may also use such data to send other marketing communications to you. Our lawful ground for this processing is either consent or legitimate interests (namely to grow our business (see Section 4).

Sensitive Data

We do not collect any Sensitive Data about you. Sensitive data refers to data that includes details about your race or ethnicity, religious or philosophical beliefs, sex life, sexual orientation, political opinions, trade union membership, information about your health and genetic and biometric data. We do not collect any information about criminal convictions and offences.

Where we are required to collect personal data by law, or under the terms of the contract between us and you do not provide us with that data when requested, we may not be able to perform the contract (for example, to deliver services to you). If you don’t provide us with the requested data, we may have to cancel a service you have ordered but if we do, we will notify you at the time.

We will only use your personal data for a purpose it was collected for or a reasonably compatible purpose if necessary. For more information on this please email us at info@johnmurphyinternational.com. In case we need to use your details for an unrelated new purpose we will let you know and explain the legal grounds for processing.

We may process your personal data without your knowledge or consent where this is required or permitted by law.

We do not carry out automated decision making or any type of automated profiling.

3.  HOW WE COLLECT YOUR PERSONAL DATA

We may collect data about you by you providing the data directly to us (for example by filling in forms on our site or by sending us emails). We may automatically collect certain data from you as you use our website by using cookies and similar technologies. Please see our cookie policy for more details about this.

We may receive data from third parties such as analytics providers such as Google based outside the EU, advertising networks such as Facebook-based outside the EU, such as search information providers such as Google based outside the EU, providers of technical, payment and delivery services, such as data brokers or aggregators.

We may also receive data from publicly available sources such as the Companies Registration Office in Ireland or equivalent elsewhere and the Electoral Register based inside the EU.

4. MARKETING COMMUNICATIONS

Our lawful ground of processing your personal data to send you marketing communications is either your consent or our legitimate interests (namely to grow our business).

Under the Privacy and Electronic Communications Regulations (PECR), we may send you marketing communications from us if (i) you made a purchase or asked for information from us about our services or (ii) you agreed to receive marketing communications and in each case you have not opted out of receiving such communications since. Under these regulations, if you are a limited company, we may send you marketing emails without your consent. However you can still opt out of receiving marketing emails from us at any time.

Before we share your personal data with any third party for their own marketing purposes we will get your express consent.

You can ask us or third parties to stop sending you marketing messages at any time by following the opt-out/unsubscribe links on any marketing message sent to you or OR by emailing us at info@johnmurphyinternational.com.

If you opt out of receiving marketing communications this opt-out does not apply to personal data provided as a result of other transactions, such as purchases, warranty registrations etc.

5.  DISCLOSURES OF YOUR PERSONAL DATA

We may have to share your personal data with the parties set out below:

Service providers who provide operational, IT and system administration services.
Professional advisers including lawyers, bankers, auditors and insurers.
Government bodies that require us to report processing activities.
Third parties to whom we sell, transfer, or merge parts of our business or our assets.
We require all third parties to whom we transfer your data to respect the security of your personal data and to treat it in accordance with the law. We only allow such third parties to process your personal data for specified purposes and in accordance with our instructions.

6.  INTERNATIONAL TRANSFERS

We are subject to the provisions of the General Data Protection Regulations (GDPR) that protect your personal data. Where we transfer your data to third parties outside of the EEA, we will ensure that certain safeguards are in place to ensure a similar degree of security for your personal data. As such:

We may transfer your personal data to countries that the European Commission have approved as providing an adequate level of protection for personal data by; or
If we use US-based providers that are part of EU-US Privacy Shield, we may transfer data to them, as they have equivalent safeguards in place; or
Where we use certain service providers who are established outside of the EEA, we may use specific contracts or codes of conduct or certification mechanisms approved by the European Commission which give personal data the same protection it has in Europe.
If none of the above safeguards is available, we may request your explicit consent to the specific transfer. You will have the right to withdraw this consent at any time.

7.  DATA SECURITY

We have put in place security measures to prevent your personal data from being accidentally lost, used, altered, disclosed, or accessed without authorisation. We also allow access to your personal data only to those employees and partners who have a business need to know such data. They will only process your personal data on our instructions and they must keep it confidential.

We have procedures in place to deal with any suspected personal data breach and will notify you and any applicable regulator of a breach if we are legally required to.

8.  DATA RETENTION

We will only retain your personal data for as long as necessary to fulfil the purposes we collected it for, including for the purposes of satisfying any legal, accounting, or reporting requirements.

When deciding what the correct time is to keep the data for, we look at its amount, nature and sensitivity, potential risk of harm from unauthorised use or disclosure, the processing purposes, if these can be achieved by other means and legal requirements.

For tax purposes the law requires us to keep basic information about our customers (including Contact, Identity, Financial and Transaction Data) for six years after they stop being customers.

In some circumstances we may anonymise your personal data for research or statistical purposes in which case we may use this information indefinitely without further notice to you.

9.  YOUR LEGAL RIGHTS

Under data protection laws you have rights in relation to your personal data that include the right to request access, correction, erasure, restriction, transfer, to object to processing, to portability of data and (where the lawful ground of processing is consent) to withdraw consent.

You can see more about these rights at:
http://gdprandyou.ie/gdpr-for-individuals/
If you wish to exercise any of the rights set out above, please email us at info@johnmurphyinternational.com.
You will not have to pay a fee to access your personal data (or to exercise any of the other rights). However, we may charge a reasonable fee if your request is clearly unfounded, repetitive or excessive or refuse to comply with your request in these circumstances.

We may need to request specific information from you to help us confirm your identity and ensure your right to access your personal data (or to exercise any of your other rights). This is a security measure to ensure that personal data is not disclosed to any person who has no right to receive it. We may also contact you to ask you for further information in relation to your request to speed up our response.

We try to respond to all legitimate requests within one month. Occasionally it may take us longer than a month if your request is particularly complex or you have made a number of requests. In this case, we will notify you.

If you are not happy with any aspect of how we collect and use your data, you have the right to complain to the Data Protection Commissioner’s Office (DPCI), the Irish supervisory authority for data protection issues. We would be grateful if you would contact us first if you do have a complaint so that we can try to resolve it for you.

10. THIRD-PARTY LINKS

This website may include links to third-party websites, plug-ins and applications. Clicking on those links or enabling those connections may allow third parties to collect or share data about you. We do not control these third-party websites and are not responsible for their privacy policies. When you leave our website, we encourage you to read the privacy policy of every website you visit.

11. COOKIES

You can set your browser to refuse all or some browser cookies, or to alert you when websites set or access cookies. If you disable or refuse cookies, please note that some parts of this website may become inaccessible or not function properly. For more information about the cookies we use, please see our cookie policy.

Get exclusive, actionable leadership insights
for leading your team via my members’
only weekly email dispatches.

We will only send you awesome stuff

Privacy Policy

Book John To Speak

  • MM slash DD slash YYYY

We will only send you awesome stuff

Privacy Policy

Subscribe with your
favourite podcast player

Choose one from below